Choose wisely from among your job offers
Big firm or start-up? There’s much to be said for each; the area you want to work in will dictate your choice
Here is a simple question. Say you have a job offer with a great package from a well-known company. You also have an offer from a small company that not many have heard of. Which one should you pick?
You are right if you said ‘the former’; you would also have been right if you picked ‘the latter’. And righter still if you said ‘it depends’. Deciding which offer to go with for your first job is not easy and depends on a lot of factors.
First is best
A job is where you spend a good deal of your life and it is important to choose well. It turns out that it is particularly so for your first job, for several reasons. “Your first job ends up making your career. Only a few choose to change their line of work later,” says Pallavi Jha, Managing Director and Chairperson, Dale Carnegie Training India.
Also, the learning curve is steep in the first five years of one’s career. Subject knowledge, operating style and best practices are all typically picked up early in one’s career and may be hard to alter later, say experts. In campus placements, you may not have the choice of refusing an offer; so it is all the more essential to choose wisely.
In the past, typically, only larger organisations went for campus placements. However, there has been a trend with even start-ups increasingly attracting young talent. An Employment Outlook Report based on a study conducted by TeamLease recently found nine of 10 start-ups claiming to increase the number of hires in 2016. This makes it, in a way, a bit more challenging for the candidate to pick among the plethora of options.
Starting the search
To start with, you need to decide which function you want to work in. If you specialised in finance, you must decide if you want to continue in this line or be a generalist. “If you want to do marketing or finance, it may be better to take up a job in that function at a large organisation which is known for that functional strength”, says Biji Kurien, former MD of Berger Paints, who entered IIM-A 50 years ago.
Experts advise that it is important to understand the role you want, prepare accordingly and select a job. For instance, while in college, you must meet industry professionals to know the daily functions of those in various job titles. It also helps to do internships, be aware of realities and choose based on what would be suitable for your skills and interest.
Bigger is better?
Larger companies may typically pay a higher salary and perks. There may also be other advantages, such as a structured HR and training process that will ease the transition from college to corporate life, notes Jha.
There may also be the comfort of a better job security at a larger organisation. “There is recognition, prestige and branding. Your seniors may also be working at the same place. There is more predictability and the company may also invest in training”, says Dorai Thodla, a technology entrepreneur who works closely with student entrepreneurs and colleges. He also adds that, often, parents prefer that their son or daughter joins a recognised company, nudging the decision.
“Till last year, start-ups were romanticised like never before in India”, says Mohit Gundecha, Co-founder & CEO, Jombay, a HR advisory firm. A lot of people wanted to join the bandwagon and be a part of the buzz. But this year, it has been a bloodbath, with many of them shutting shop or laying off. “Quite naturally, there are concerns about joining a start-up, especially at the start of one’s career. People are not ready to take a leap of faith any more”, he says.
But would you be trading off learning for comfort and choosing to be small fish in a big pond? Experts differ in their views. Kurien, who joined Asian Paints when it was not yet a large firm and grew with it, says that the learning curve is steeper in a small company. “Bigger companies put you in one slot and you cannot see the business as a whole”, he says.
However, Pradeep Kumar, who works for a large organisation and advises many young start-ups, says that the belief that one can learn a lot, have freedom and create an impact in start-ups is a ‘myth’. “What you can do and cannot do would depend on the stage of the start-up, priorities and lot of external factors. It is possible that you may not be able to execute your ideas in a small company; it is very possible to do a lot and learn a lot at a large organisation”, he says.
Thodla says that big names such as Google offer a lot of avenues to learn and grow. “B-schools are geared to think on scale and this fits what larger companies want. The case studies are on MNCs, not often on smaller firms”, he says.
Also, the lack of structure in smaller firms may not be suitable for many. “Everything may be up in the air and only those who are driven and are self-learners may be able to learn”, says Jha.
Small is beautiful
For those who can navigate chaos, and manage on a smaller pay cheque, smaller firms can however offer good opportunities. “You get a T shaped learning at a small company — deep knowledge in few areas and broader learning in a variety of verticals”, says Thodla. Also, those who want to start their own ventures may benefit from the practical learning.
“Presumably every MBA wants to be a CEO some day. If that is the long-term career plan, it is better to start with a smaller company. You can learn multiple functions and can grow with the company”, advises Kurien.
But given the many risks, it is imperative to choose your employer wisely. The term ‘start-up’ is used a bit loosely and you must know what stage they are in to decide on the suitability. “It may be safer to opt for start-ups that see customer traction and have possibly received some funding. Very small start-ups may offer greater learning, but may be too risky”, says Thodla.
Kunal Sen, Senior Vice-President, TeamLease Services, lists three main aspects you must deliberate on. One, look at the qualities of the founders — most start-up failures are due to weak leadership. Two, find out the work environment and the company’s HR policies for your job profile. This is important as the work can be hectic and stressful. Three, look at your job role including your responsibilities, targets and growth path. “There may not be a clear description of what the job entails, and the start-up may expect you to perform a number of tasks”, says Sen.
What to pick
So how does one select one’s first employer? Experts advise that, rather than look at size or sector, you must focus on the quality of work and how you fit into it. For instance, Sen observes that lack of a clear job description in a small company may bother some people, but may be seen as a perk by others.
Also, most smaller firms don’t want employees who are there to just do a job but want them to push the envelope. “You should evaluate if you have the ability to challenge the status quo and mediocrity. Individuals who can’t live up to the quality or can’t challenge the mediocrity will struggle to enjoy and sustain in a start-up”, cautions Gundecha.Thodla advises that students run their own business even while in college to see if they enjoy the process and choose accordingly. Pradeep Kumar is agnostic to the company’s size and believes that, at the end of day, the choice would depend a lot on the culture of the organisation you are joining. “Irrespective of what you pick, talk to your boss and your team; understand more about your role and what is expected of you; evaluate how the growth path might look like, before you sign up”, he says.
Kurien says that what is taught in B-school is a lot of management techniques and rational analysis which are left-brain based. “Business is not just that. You need a lot of intuition to do well in business”, he says. And so it is in the business of deciding who your get your first pay-cheque from.
—
This article was first published in Business Line on Campus:
Latest Blogs
The HR Recruitment Process: More Than Just Hiring People
Walk into any organisation, startup or multinational, and ask what keeps the engine running. It won’t just be tech, products, or processes. It’s people. But...
Read MoreHow Staffing Partners Transform Recruitment & Selection Process
The recruitment and selection process in HRM (Human Resource Management) has evolved significantly, and it plays a pivotal role in shaping the future of any...
Read MoreTalent Acquisition vs Recruitment in Workforce Planning
In many boardroom conversations, “talent acquisition” and “recruitment” are used interchangeably, but the reality is, they’re not the same. While both deal with bringing people...
Read MoreEvolution of Human Resource Management in India
The evolution of human resource management in India is a compelling story of how businesses have transformed their approach to people. What started as a...
Read More5 Key Manpower Supply Strategies for Hiring Better Talent
In today’s competitive job market, ensuring a reliable manpower supply is critical for business continuity and growth. Whether managing large-scale operations or expanding your business,...
Read MoreUnique Courses: Banking and Finance – Talk money, bulls and bears
An article in Career 360 talks about various courses that will help candidates to build a banking career; along with inputs from Neeti Sharma.
Jeremiah Quinlan, Dean of Undergraduate Admissions at Yale University pointed out to Careers360 sometimes back what global companies look for in students. “In today’s modern world, you know it’s not really about all the skills that you know, it’s how quickly you can learn what you need to learn when you start a new job,” he said. Quinlan is bang on target when it comes to Banking and Financial Services as these services require not just functional experts, but those who are quick learners as well.
Manpower requirement
The projected manpower requirement of the Banking, Financial Services and Insurance (BFSI) sector work force by 2022 is 8.5 million – which is an increase of about 4 – 4.5 million from where we stand today. A number of institutions are offering programmes in collaboration with industry bodies and organisations to fill the gap in demand for qualified professionals in the domain. Neeti Sharma, Senior Vice President TeamLease Services says, “Banking and financial services is one of the burgeoning sectors in the region. By 2017, the region alone is expected to create around 33% of the total employment generated by the BFSI industry. We are confident that such collaborations will not only enable students to take advantage of the opportunity and get gainful employment, it will also create a pool of skilled talent for the industry to recruit from.”
FAME degrees
Broadly concerned with the management of money, finance is one of the subjects very popular at both undergraduate and postgraduate levels. Finance, Accounting, Management and Economics are commonly referred to as the FAME group of subjects. An undergraduate or postgraduate degree in FAME prepares you for a career in a range of sectors, including banking, financial markets and insurance.
Do you have it in you?
If you have a good academic background with a nose for numbers, you can surely get admission for finance degrees which cover technical and theoretical knowledge. In general, a course in any of the streams of finance will cover topics like how to measure wealth, how finance shape the decisions of companies, government policies etc. Accounting, mathematical methods, macro and microeconomics and IT are all covered under finance degrees. At later stages of specialization, you will get in depth knowledge in taxation, audit, business strategy, business and employment law, management accounting, advanced accounting theory and risk management. Your job roles could be in commercial or consumer banking, investment banking, managing wealth, insurance, capital markets or even real estate.
Select courses in B&F
Though a number of BBA and MBA courses have specialization in Banking and Finance, they majorly cover management aspects rather than specific roles. One the other hand some programmes run in collaboration with banks or the Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE) or the National Stock Exchange of India (NSE) are sort of customized programmes focused on industry needs and make you job-ready from Day-1. Both the stock exchanges run short-term and long-term programmes on their own or in collaborations with other universities. Federal Manipal School of Banking (FMSB) which is an exclusive partnership forged between Federal Bank and Manipal Global Education services offers Post Graduate Diploma in Banking and Financial Services. Axis Bank Young Bankers is a one year, full-time residential programme conducted at two campuses; Manipal Global Education in Bangalore and Amity Global Business School in Noida.
Popular Courses in Banking and Finance
Course
Institute (Partner)
Postgraduate Diploma in
Banking and Finance
Federal Manipal School of Banking
(Federal Bank)
Post Graduate Program in Banking & Finance (PGPBF)
BSE Institute Ltd
Axis Bank Young Banker’s Program
Manipal Global Education Services & Amity Global Business School (Axis Bank)
MBA – Finance & Banking
NIIT University (ICICI Bank)
BBA (Financial Management) with Specialization in Capital Markets
Ganpat University (NSE)
BBA (Hons.) in Financial Markets
ITM University, Gwalior (NSE)
Note: Some of the programmes may not have AICTE approval though they are valued in the job market
Vocation focused courses
There are also vocationally inclined programmes like those launched by Tata Institute of Social Sciences -School of Vocational Education (TISS-SVE). “Most professions have a well-defined and structured academic path. However, when it comes to becoming a Banker or a Loan Officer or Equity Trader etc., the academic path suddenly becomes hazy. There aren’t many universities that offer formal qualifications to help students build successful careers in the Banking, Financial Services & Insurance (BFSI) domain,” says Thyagarajan Balasubramanian, Vertical Anchor, Stratadigm Education & Training Pvt. Ltd (TISS SVE). “It is in this background that we have launched BFSI-focused, industry-relevant, short-term and long-term courses at the UG, PG and Certifications level. The industry-academia relationship has been taken to a new level by us,” he added.
Thyagarajan BalasubramanianThyagarajan Balasubramanian,
Vertical Anchor,
Stratadigm Education & Training Pvt. Ltd, TISS SVE
There aren’t many universities that offer formal qualifications to help students build successful careers in the Banking, Financial Services & Insurance domain. The few that do offer BFSI courses do not seem to have an industry-aligned curriculum or seem to focus more on theoretical aspects. It is in this background, that TISS-SVE has launched BFSI-focused, industry-relevant courses of various duration.
Employment sectors
Banking sector roles include roles in core banking, retail, private, corporate, investment, cards, etc. Financial Services may include stockbroking, payment gateways, and mutual funds. A lot of data processing, application testing and software development activities are outsourced to companies that specialize in this domain.
While Digital banking is progressively becoming the preferred way of conducting banking transactions, it brings with it the threats of data security, hacking, password thefts etc. Owing to the sensitivity of customer-information and increasing information security threats, information security expertise is another key area for banks. This is yet another area where professionals with requisite experience can pursue a banking career.
Other options in financial sector
As we know Finance is one of the fastest growing sectors not only in India but across the globe and there is great demand for professionals like Chartered Accountant (course offered by Institute of Chartered Accountants of India – ICAI); Company Secretary (CS) by Institute of Company Secretaries of India (ICSI) and Cost and Work Accountant (CWA) by Institute of Cost Accountants of India. Any student who has passed 10+2 can register for these three courses. More or less all three have some common papers but the way you learn core subjects differ.
A thorough understanding of banking concepts, tools, will ensure your productivity. So, invest your time in learning and preparing for a banking job so that not only you get the job, but you are able to prosper in it from Day-1.
Deodutta KuraneEXPERT COLUMN
Deodutta Kurane,
Group President,
Human Capital Management, YES Bank
The Indian banking sector is in a state of transition with new-age, innovative banking models already being rolled out with product and service offerings targeted at different customer segments. The banking staff responsible for the design, delivery and service of specific offerings needs to have differentiated skills and competencies aligned to the respective product and customer segment.
As in any other field, the positions requiring more specialized knowledge/skills command a premium. Hence candidates aspiring for an accelerated career growth in this sector need to equip themselves with the requisite knowledge well in time so that they can capitalize on the ever-increasing opportunities. There are also some specialized courses required from a regulatory perspective mandated by IRDA, SEBI etc. Roles in BFSI range from the front line sales/service positions to Relationship Management roles and the more specialized product roles including Trade Finance, Financial Markets, Cash Management Risk Management, Investment banking, Financial Technology etc.
Deriving meaningful and predictive insights from large data is an emerging area in information technology and analytics, applicable not only in banking, but across all industries and sectors. In the years to come, this will become a key driver for strategy formulation to product development, design & delivery, risk management and ‘augmented’ experience.
It can be truly said that banking is the confluence of various enriching and attractive career options. Candidates with the right attitude, skill sets and mind set have a plethora of growth opportunities which can culminate in exciting and highly rewarding professional destinations.
This article was published in Career 360
Latest Blogs
The HR Recruitment Process: More Than Just Hiring People
Walk into any organisation, startup or multinational, and ask what keeps the engine running. It won’t just be tech, products, or processes. It’s people. But...
Read MoreHow Staffing Partners Transform Recruitment & Selection Process
The recruitment and selection process in HRM (Human Resource Management) has evolved significantly, and it plays a pivotal role in shaping the future of any...
Read MoreTalent Acquisition vs Recruitment in Workforce Planning
In many boardroom conversations, “talent acquisition” and “recruitment” are used interchangeably, but the reality is, they’re not the same. While both deal with bringing people...
Read MoreEvolution of Human Resource Management in India
The evolution of human resource management in India is a compelling story of how businesses have transformed their approach to people. What started as a...
Read More5 Key Manpower Supply Strategies for Hiring Better Talent
In today’s competitive job market, ensuring a reliable manpower supply is critical for business continuity and growth. Whether managing large-scale operations or expanding your business,...
Read MoreGovt ties up with private firms for real-time tracking of jobs
An article in Mint talks about how government is partnering with private entities to collect jobs data and build a platform to aggregate employment openings in real time; along with inputs from Manish Sabharwal.
The centre has formed partnerships with 20 entities including job boards and staffing firms to provide access to its vast pool of over 37 million registered job seekers.
The Union government is partnering with private entities to collect jobs data and build a platform to aggregate employment openings in real time.
It has formed partnerships with 20 entities including job boards and staffing companies to provide access to its vast pool of over 37 million registered job seekers to job openings and provide it with real time data on jobs availability in India.
“Bringing jobs to seekers is more important than who is bringing it,” said Pravin Srivastava, deputy director general, employment at the labour ministry. “What we are building is a sector agnostic and promoter agnostic collaborative platform which will be beneficial to job seekers.”
As many as 12 million people are entering India’s labour market every year. The proportion of people in the labour force declined from 43% in 2004-05 to 39.5% in 2011-12 with a sharp drop in the female participation rate from 29% to 21.9% in the same period, according to the labour ministry.
“First, we created the national career service portal, and then, we are tying up with private players of all hues and looks to build a real-time database on jobs,” Srivastava said. “If large players like Shine.com give us a bigger visibility, another player FreshersWorld will connect first-time job seekers with jobs. We have tied up with players who are in formal as well as in informal space.”
The government has understood that aggregating jobs is a challenge and the best way to do is through collaboration, said Vivek Chandok, chief executive of website Saral Rozgar, a jobs website run by Tech Mahindra Ltd. “When you create an online platform, it has its own challenge of language, last mile connectivity and bringing blue collar workers on board. “Here, we come to the picture—who can bring white, blue and grey collar workers on one platform,” Chandok said.
Manish Sabharwal, chairman of staffing company TeamLease Services, said the country does not have a job problem but wage problem and the efforts everyone is making is to take informal workforce to the formal workforce pool.
“For a clear picture of the number of jobs available, one must keep a track of both formal and informal private jobs available and the government is trying to achieve that,” said Nirmal Singh, chief executive of job assessment and matching company Wheebox that has tied up with the labour ministry.
Aggregating jobs in one platform will give a sense of what is available and where is the gap, he said.
“It’s a win-win for government, private job boards like us and employers,” said Amit Garg, executive director (Digital) at HT Media Ltd, which runs Shine.com and is also the publisher of Mint.
At any given point of time, Shine.com has between 150,000 to 200,000 job postings and when big companies like us come together it will improve the visibility of government’s efforts, Garg said.
“While the government’s efforts will get more visibility, job portals will get more traffic because the talent pool registered with the government and the employers will have more choice,” he explained. “Now technology is available to aggregate jobs in real-time and government can make use of our resources and postings to build a system that will help in gap analysis and better policy making.”
—
This article was published in Mint
Latest Blogs
The HR Recruitment Process: More Than Just Hiring People
Walk into any organisation, startup or multinational, and ask what keeps the engine running. It won’t just be tech, products, or processes. It’s people. But...
Read MoreHow Staffing Partners Transform Recruitment & Selection Process
The recruitment and selection process in HRM (Human Resource Management) has evolved significantly, and it plays a pivotal role in shaping the future of any...
Read MoreTalent Acquisition vs Recruitment in Workforce Planning
In many boardroom conversations, “talent acquisition” and “recruitment” are used interchangeably, but the reality is, they’re not the same. While both deal with bringing people...
Read MoreEvolution of Human Resource Management in India
The evolution of human resource management in India is a compelling story of how businesses have transformed their approach to people. What started as a...
Read More5 Key Manpower Supply Strategies for Hiring Better Talent
In today’s competitive job market, ensuring a reliable manpower supply is critical for business continuity and growth. Whether managing large-scale operations or expanding your business,...
Read MoreIIT-B median salary offer rises 6.5%
An article in Hindustan Times talks about how the median salary offered by companies at IIT-B has increased by 6.5% during last academic year; along with inputs from Rituparna Chakraborty.
The median salary offered by companies at Indian Institute of Technology Bombay (IIT-B) increased by 6.5% during last academic year, reveals the institute’s placement report.
The report put the annual median salary at Rs9.8 lakh in 2015-16, up from Rs9.2 lakh in 2014-15. In other words, half the IITians received salary packages upward of approximately Rs10 lakh per annum in the previous academic year.
While the highest salaries often touched Rs1 crore, the majority of students got much smaller pay-scales. The institute doesn’t provide the average salary figures — which indicate overall variation in packages.
Nonetheless, the data reveals that students received better packages this year, with more companies offering higher salaries.
For example, in the last placement season, 96 companies offered more than Rs11 lakh per annum, the highest bracket (see the box), to 435 (38%) out of 1,143 candidates. In 2014-15, 365 (33%) out of 1,118 students received packages in the highest bracket from 74 companies.
While the number of candidates who were offered jobs didn’t change significantly during last academic year, the count of companies which offered jobs rose from 274 in 2014-15 to 308 in 2015-16.
In the recent years, the premier institute has been witnessing a steady, if not a sizeable, swelling of packages. In the three years between 2010-11 and 2013-14, the median salary offered by companies visiting IIT-B rose from Rs7.6 lakh to Rs9.1 lakh.
Rituparna Chakraborty, executive vice-president at TeamLease Serices, a human resources consulting agency, said that if while the current rise in median salary is “acceptable” — even if one is to factor in inflation — it’s not “dramatic”.
“The job market has saturated for engineers and even the IT sector, which remains the largest recruiter of engineers, isn’t hiring in large numbers. However, compared to the starting salaries of engineering graduates from colleges other than IITs, many of whom start with Rs10,000 a month, the packages offered to IITians are good,” she said. She added that unless the Prime Minister’s Make-in-India initiative bears fruits, the salaries won’t see a jump at the premier institute.
According to the institute, the majority of its past recruiters came back last year and recruited in large numbers. “IIT-B graduates are in demand among the top recruiters in various segments of the economy. [The upcoming placement season] will be even more crucial in the coming years as campus placements become more intense due to increased corporate competitiveness, heightened student aspirations, a rapidly changing job market and an increasingly insecure global economy,” concludes the report.
This article was published in Hindustan Times
Latest Blogs
The HR Recruitment Process: More Than Just Hiring People
Walk into any organisation, startup or multinational, and ask what keeps the engine running. It won’t just be tech, products, or processes. It’s people. But...
Read MoreHow Staffing Partners Transform Recruitment & Selection Process
The recruitment and selection process in HRM (Human Resource Management) has evolved significantly, and it plays a pivotal role in shaping the future of any...
Read MoreTalent Acquisition vs Recruitment in Workforce Planning
In many boardroom conversations, “talent acquisition” and “recruitment” are used interchangeably, but the reality is, they’re not the same. While both deal with bringing people...
Read MoreEvolution of Human Resource Management in India
The evolution of human resource management in India is a compelling story of how businesses have transformed their approach to people. What started as a...
Read More5 Key Manpower Supply Strategies for Hiring Better Talent
In today’s competitive job market, ensuring a reliable manpower supply is critical for business continuity and growth. Whether managing large-scale operations or expanding your business,...
Read MoreHave job seekers become wary of offers from startups
An article in youstory.com talks about how job seekers have become more cautious while considering offers from startups as they present substantial risk to their long-term goals; along with inputs from Sudeep Sen.
According to experts, job seekers have become more cautious while considering offers from startups as they present substantial risk to their long-term goals.
Hiring consultancy Michael Page’s Director Ankit Agarwala told PTI.
With the premier tech school IIT Bombay blacklisting nine startups, job seekers have become more cautious before accepting offers from them. There could be more job seekers declining offers from these companies as they will weigh the substantial risk they need to take while making such career moves as they consider their long-term professional goals.
Recently, IIT Bombay had blacklisted nine startups for one year as a penalty for various violations, including revoking offers to some graduates. Startups are generally hiring cautiously and focusing mainly on critical or essential roles that will directly contribute to the productivity of the organisation, Agarwala said.
Compared to the previous year, we are seeing tighter control on head count expenditure… there is a strategic move from firms to hire mainly for key roles instead of undergoing large scale expansion, he added.
It will mean that these startups will need to work harder in attracting talent in order to convince senior and high-potential candidates to come onboard, he said.
Echoing a similar view, TeamLease Assistant Vice President Sudeep Sen said that with time to come, startups will be cautious to hire and the incumbents will be doing deeper scrutiny as well.
The onus would be on the startups to have a clear business plan, including reliable funding sources, to build the confidence of senior candidates in the business and financial stability of the organisation, he pointed out.
GlobalHunt Managing Director Sunil Goel said top institutes want to give a very good start to their students, which they think should not be measured only on salary offered but also validity and assurance to honour the offer letter and sustainability of the job. The IIT-Bombay ban on nine startups would have about 15-20 percent impact on other premier institutes inviting such companies into their campuses, Sen said.
Such companies have to pass through acid test of ‘start up employer qualifier’, where valid business plans, long-term stay, return on investment (ROI) and investors, among others, will be scrutinised, he added.
Moreover, the millennials are still excited about startups as they get multi-activity experience in a very short time, contrary to a structured system at the initial stage of their career, GlobalHunt’s Goel felt. However, Goel added that good business models with decent and sizeable investment back-ups are likely to attract the pool of best talent available and will continue to grow at 15-20 percent in coming years.
This article was published in yourstory.com
Latest Blogs
The HR Recruitment Process: More Than Just Hiring People
Walk into any organisation, startup or multinational, and ask what keeps the engine running. It won’t just be tech, products, or processes. It’s people. But...
Read MoreHow Staffing Partners Transform Recruitment & Selection Process
The recruitment and selection process in HRM (Human Resource Management) has evolved significantly, and it plays a pivotal role in shaping the future of any...
Read MoreTalent Acquisition vs Recruitment in Workforce Planning
In many boardroom conversations, “talent acquisition” and “recruitment” are used interchangeably, but the reality is, they’re not the same. While both deal with bringing people...
Read MoreEvolution of Human Resource Management in India
The evolution of human resource management in India is a compelling story of how businesses have transformed their approach to people. What started as a...
Read More5 Key Manpower Supply Strategies for Hiring Better Talent
In today’s competitive job market, ensuring a reliable manpower supply is critical for business continuity and growth. Whether managing large-scale operations or expanding your business,...
Read MoreUrbanisation, less regulations key to job creation in India: panel
An article in Mint talks about how job creation in India can be boosted; along with inputs from Manish Sabharwal.
Two key areas — more regular wage employment and female employment—need urgent attention, say experts.
Over 600 million people in India are under 35 and an efficient workforce can help boost the country’s productivity thus economy.
India’s job problem is complex, and to create more jobs, the country must reduce regulations for industries, focus on urbanisation and boost manufacturing, a panel of experts from industry and World Bank said Wednesday at the India Summit organised by The Economist.
The question is whether India can create a million jobs every month, said Martin Rama, chief economist, South Asia at World Bank.
Rama said there is a gap, and the number of jobs are falling. India, he said, has two key areas which need urgent attention: one, more regular wage employment, and two, female employment.
The female labor force participation rate in India is less than 23%. Around 20% of the total labour force earns regular wages.
“Unless we reduce regulatory cholesterol and improve the efficiency of people, it will be a tough environment. The role of the government is to create a conducive atmosphere,” said Manish Sabharwal, chairman of Teamlease Services, a staffing company.
He said India does not have a job problem but wage problem, and efforts must be made to shift the informal workforce to formal job creation in India.
Urbanisation, overregulation, and human capital are three areas that need urgent attention to address the employment problem.
Over-regulation and the multiplicity of laws are restricting the growth of industries, he said. India has 63 million companies, and 12 million of them do not even have offices. Of the total number of companies, just 18,000 have a paid-up capital of Rs. 10 crore each, Sabharwal explained.
Suraj Saharan, co-founder and chief people officer of Delhivery, a logistics company serving e-commerce firms, echoed the sentiments of the Teamlease chairman. The compliance burden is huge, said Saharan, adding that there are too many laws and too much paperwork.
Saharan said the country needs to have a database of workers to facilitate clean hiring, as background checks on employees right now is a tedious process.
However, all three believe that the demographic bulge in India is not a problem, and things have started improving over the last few years. Over 600 million people in India are under 35, and an efficient workforce can help boost the country’s productivity thus economy.
—
This article was published in Mint
Latest Blogs
The HR Recruitment Process: More Than Just Hiring People
Walk into any organisation, startup or multinational, and ask what keeps the engine running. It won’t just be tech, products, or processes. It’s people. But...
Read MoreHow Staffing Partners Transform Recruitment & Selection Process
The recruitment and selection process in HRM (Human Resource Management) has evolved significantly, and it plays a pivotal role in shaping the future of any...
Read MoreTalent Acquisition vs Recruitment in Workforce Planning
In many boardroom conversations, “talent acquisition” and “recruitment” are used interchangeably, but the reality is, they’re not the same. While both deal with bringing people...
Read MoreEvolution of Human Resource Management in India
The evolution of human resource management in India is a compelling story of how businesses have transformed their approach to people. What started as a...
Read More5 Key Manpower Supply Strategies for Hiring Better Talent
In today’s competitive job market, ensuring a reliable manpower supply is critical for business continuity and growth. Whether managing large-scale operations or expanding your business,...
Read MoreWhen the law needs to catch up with reality
The size of the contract labour force in India’s largest carmaker Maruti Suzuki is reflective of how the corporate world is responding to the changed dynamics of the labour market. The share of contract workers in the automobile company’s total workforce has grown from 32 per cent in 2013-14 to 42 per cent in 2015-16.
Around 55 percent of the 537 million tonnes of coal mined by public sector behemoth Coal India during 2015-16 was done by 65,000 contractual workers. This ratio is poised to increase to at least 58 per cent in the current financial year.
The Centre remains one of the biggest employers of contract labour. According to the Seventh Pay Commission, the Centre spent Rs.300 crore in 2012-13 on contract or temporary workers.
The growing demand for contract workers is in line with the global trend of seeking employment flexibility. Over the past 25 years unionisation has Men across the world. Job outsourcing and dispersal of the workforce in multiple countries have become commonplace even for medium-sized companies in developed countries. As developing countries like China, Bangladesh, Egypt, Brazil and Colombia are changing their labour laws to permit flexible hiring, developed nations with strong trade unions have been forced to make regulations favouring temporary hiring.
Take, for instance, the concept of zero-hour contract, where the employer has no obligation to provide any stipulated hours of work but the employee is required to be available when the employer needs his service. This is the latest example of flexible hiring in Britain.
In India, companies, particularly those in labour-intensive sectors like automobiles, construction and mining, usually refrain from hiring permanent workers for project-based requirements, as termination requires issuing a notice, payment of compensation, and intimation to the government.
India’s temporary workforce is governed by the Contract Labour (Regulation & Abolition) Act, 1970. An establishment that employs 20 or more workmen on any day of the preceding 12 months can employ temporary workers upon obtaining a valid certificate of registration.
Trade unions say companies prefer the use of contract workers because of the cost arbitrage. Contract workers are paid much less than regular workers. This year’s Economic Survey estimates wages are on an average 20 times higher in the formal sector than in the informal sector.
“When the work in an automobile factory is of perennial nature, why should a company be allowed to hire contract workers?” asks D L Sachdeva, general secretary, All India Trade Union Congress. Sachdeva says there should be no difference between a permanent employee and a contract worker who is equally experienced and does the same job with equal efficiency.
Industry executives point out that the presence of the word “abolition” in the Act sends a wrong message. “We employ people in ground-handling services according to our need. You can’t expect pay parity between workers with experience of 12 years and those with one year,” says an executive with an airline company.
Legal experts point out lacunae in the law and the fact that the judiciary has interpreted the law in various ways. The Supreme Court in its judgment in the RK Panda vs Steel Authority of India case said workers continuing in employment for 10 years should be absorbed as regular employees. But in a separate case, Steel Authority of India vs National Water Front Workers, the court ruled there was no provision in the law implying absorption of contract workers.
Experts say the archaic law forces many companies to subvert it, denying adequate legal protection to contract workers. “When this law was made, only the bipartisan nature of negotiation was kept in mind. It has to change in the current scenario,” says Rituparna Chakraborty, senior vice-president of staffing company TeamLease.
Moreover, the process of hiring contract workers is a tedious one. An organisation with offices across the country has to seek registration by declaring the number of vendors who supply contract workers in each office, based on which forms are issued by separate states. Every vendor in every premise has to seek a licence on that basis. Many companies find ways to subvert the law by hiring contract workers through third-party agents. “The government should make licensing for staffing firms compulsory to weed out fly-by-night operators,” says Chakraborty.
The government is waking up to the reality of flexi-staffing. It recently allowed temporary workers in the garment industry. The decision to set the minimum wage of 110,000 a month for contract workers is another step in that direction. “Contract work is now a reality; the government understands that, and is working towards facilitating it,” noted Shankar Agarwal, secretary in the labour and employment ministry.
FOR MORE EFFECTIVE LAW
- Industry wants simplification of the Act for easy compliance
- Register staffing firms to weed out fly-by-night operators
- Labour unions want pay parity between regular and contract workers
- Amendment of the Act to remove the word “abolition”
This article was published in Business Standard
Latest Blogs
The HR Recruitment Process: More Than Just Hiring People
Walk into any organisation, startup or multinational, and ask what keeps the engine running. It won’t just be tech, products, or processes. It’s people. But...
Read MoreHow Staffing Partners Transform Recruitment & Selection Process
The recruitment and selection process in HRM (Human Resource Management) has evolved significantly, and it plays a pivotal role in shaping the future of any...
Read MoreTalent Acquisition vs Recruitment in Workforce Planning
In many boardroom conversations, “talent acquisition” and “recruitment” are used interchangeably, but the reality is, they’re not the same. While both deal with bringing people...
Read MoreEvolution of Human Resource Management in India
The evolution of human resource management in India is a compelling story of how businesses have transformed their approach to people. What started as a...
Read More5 Key Manpower Supply Strategies for Hiring Better Talent
In today’s competitive job market, ensuring a reliable manpower supply is critical for business continuity and growth. Whether managing large-scale operations or expanding your business,...
Read MoreVocational courses: Maharashtra sees 7.5% rise in demand in 2016, says report
An article in Indian Express, talks about signaling value report by TeamLease; along with inputs from Rituparna Chakraborty.
The report further says that skills education accounts for 4 percent of the overall education industry market size in terms of revenue.
VOCATIONAL COURSES saw a 7.5 percent rise in demand across the state this year, even as more than 1.17 lakh students were admitted to Industrial Training Institutes (ITI), a report by TeamLease, a human resource consultant, has said. Around 92 per cent seats have been filled in government-run ITIs, as against private ITIs which saw fewer takers with 77.4 per cent seats filled.
While there has been a rise in demand, the degree may not correspond to the requirement for skilled labour force in the country, the report says. Only 2 percent of the labour force is formally trained and 8 percent acquire skills on the job. The demand supply gap is stark with 12.8 million people entering the workforce every year, stated the report.
The report further says that skills education accounts for 4 percent of the overall education industry market size in terms of revenue.
The report blames ‘low-status’ stigma attached to vocational courses for the low enrollment statistics. It says that those with degrees are preferred by industries over those with ITI certificates.
“Students joining ITIs don’t see the benefit of a vocational course in their professions, especially when compared to mainstream degrees such as engineering,” said Rituparna Chakraborty, co-founder and Executive Vice-President of TeamLease.
Chakraborty said the outdated and archaic curriculum was to blame. “There is a need to overhaul the entire syllabus at ITIs,” she said.
Meanwhile Nitin More, a former ITI student union member, said ITI certificate holders are technically sounder than their engineering counterparts owing to the practical training.
He said ITI certificate courses are a way out for those who want to earn a living even while studying.
The TeamLease report said short-term skill development courses are the way forward — ‘courses that are focused on specific, job-relevant skills and which take between two and six months for a candidate to complete.’
This article was published in Indian Express
Latest Blogs
The HR Recruitment Process: More Than Just Hiring People
Walk into any organisation, startup or multinational, and ask what keeps the engine running. It won’t just be tech, products, or processes. It’s people. But...
Read MoreHow Staffing Partners Transform Recruitment & Selection Process
The recruitment and selection process in HRM (Human Resource Management) has evolved significantly, and it plays a pivotal role in shaping the future of any...
Read MoreTalent Acquisition vs Recruitment in Workforce Planning
In many boardroom conversations, “talent acquisition” and “recruitment” are used interchangeably, but the reality is, they’re not the same. While both deal with bringing people...
Read MoreEvolution of Human Resource Management in India
The evolution of human resource management in India is a compelling story of how businesses have transformed their approach to people. What started as a...
Read More5 Key Manpower Supply Strategies for Hiring Better Talent
In today’s competitive job market, ensuring a reliable manpower supply is critical for business continuity and growth. Whether managing large-scale operations or expanding your business,...
Read MoreHave a failed startup? Let it shine on your CV
Four years ago, Suyog Agrawal quit his job as a research analyst to launch his own food startup, Zodiac Foods. However, reaching break-even seemed a distant dream in spite of all the effort he could make and investment he could muster.
“Considering my personal responsibilities, I decided to find a job,” says Agrawal. In no time he found one with Genpact. “A reference in my resume to the startup that failed did not subject me to embarrassing or demeaning questions,” Agrawal says.
Genpact, a modern company and one of the pioneers of the business process outsourcing revolution in India, is not alone in valuing people with failed startups on their resume. Dabur, Book My Show, Paytm, Godrej and RPG Group are hunting for ex-entrepreneurs, whom they find to be highly-skilled, self-motivated, and creative, with good salesmanship and networking skills.
These companies say they receive 10 to 15 resumes every quarter from candidates with failed startups on their resumes. They do not need to hide the failure because recruiters have come to realise they transformed a concept into reality, and would have learned something along the way.
“Personally, I am fond of such candidates. They are mature, and the best thing is they know what not to do,” says Supratik Bhattacharyya, vice-president, talent management, at RPG Enterprises.
Multinational technology giant IBM seeks out these candidates. It just hired one whose firm was working on internet and analytics solutions using open-source technology. “We were looking for a senior executive with domain strength in analytics. His entrepreneurial experience made him the apt choice for this role,” says Dilpreet Singh, vice-president, HR, at IBM India and South Asia.
Then, of course, there are startups that are keen to hire people with failed startups. And it is not just about the brotherhood of entrepreneurship. The hiring startups believe the failure would have taught critical lessons in what not to do.
Ankur Anand, who heads experience and marketing at co-working space provider InstaOffice, had failed twice as an entrepreneur, first with a B2B marketplace for coffee, and then a travel startup. Says Vikas Lakhani, co-founder, InstaOffice: “Ankur had underestimated the need for resources, which hampered his ability to execute. But he had developed a knack for deconstructing problems and defining a solution into a list of actionable items. It’s critical for us to be able to maintain a certain level of standardisation in the experience across our spaces.”
Even a company like Deoitte, an audit and consulting firm that values specialisation, likes entrepreneurs, even failed ones, for their felicity with mixed roles. “I have hired several entrepreneurs who failed. They are like sharks in fish tanks. These guys, by nature, are disruptive and flexible, and have strong communication skills. People around startup guys in a traditional organisation get to learn a lot from them,” says SV Nathan, chief talent officer at Deloitte India.
All these companies hire failed entrepreneurs knowing that they may not hang around for long. Once they have tasted entrepreneurship, they are likely to try it again. But while they are around, they teach others the value of resources, and leave behind invaluable ideas. The challenge for the employer is to match their aspirations. “We are predisposed towards such employees, but it also involves the risk of losing them as they always have the desire to build a great company on their own,” says a spokesperson for Paytm.
However, it is not all rosy for failed entrepreneurs. For all the attractiveness of their maturity and their ideas, employers are stingy in paying them. “Most of the organisations hire them at their existing salaries, with average increments ranging between zero to 10%,” says Rituparna Chakraborty, co-founder of Teamlease Services, the staffing firm.
This article was publisshed in Hindustan Times
Latest Blogs
The HR Recruitment Process: More Than Just Hiring People
Walk into any organisation, startup or multinational, and ask what keeps the engine running. It won’t just be tech, products, or processes. It’s people. But...
Read MoreHow Staffing Partners Transform Recruitment & Selection Process
The recruitment and selection process in HRM (Human Resource Management) has evolved significantly, and it plays a pivotal role in shaping the future of any...
Read MoreTalent Acquisition vs Recruitment in Workforce Planning
In many boardroom conversations, “talent acquisition” and “recruitment” are used interchangeably, but the reality is, they’re not the same. While both deal with bringing people...
Read MoreEvolution of Human Resource Management in India
The evolution of human resource management in India is a compelling story of how businesses have transformed their approach to people. What started as a...
Read More5 Key Manpower Supply Strategies for Hiring Better Talent
In today’s competitive job market, ensuring a reliable manpower supply is critical for business continuity and growth. Whether managing large-scale operations or expanding your business,...
Read MoreDespite pink slips, job prospects not all that bad: Experts
An article in Business Standard highlights HR experts views on the recent layoffs in startups and IT companies; along with inputs from Rituparna Chakraborty.
Reports of layoffs in Start-ups and IT sector notwithstanding, HR experts believe these pink slips are due to a mix of non-performance and margin pressure and the overall outlook is not that bleak, with medium and high skilled jobs likely to see continued growth.
Layoffs are becoming pretty common these days as there were recent reports of job loss in Flipkart, Askme, Ola and Infosys, among others. But experts feel that layoffs help companies survive and trim costs.
They added that employees need to upgrade their skills on a regular basis.
“Layoffs are largely triggered by three developments – redundancies, termination of projects and automation of L1 roles,” said Rituparna Chakraborty, TeamLease Services Co-founder and Senior Vice-President.
She predicted that there will be immediate job cuts of people with redundant skills and underperformers.
For L1 (level 1) roles, more non-engineers are likely to be hired or some of the activities could be automated, she said, adding that it will trigger need for constant skill upgrades.
The IT and start-up industry is in a state of flux, driven by two factors — margin pressures and adaptation of emerging automation and artificial intelligence tools. Hence, constant upgradation of skills is key to success of an employee under this new reality.
“Multiple analyst reports indicate that medium and high skilled jobs are expected to continue to grow at a fast clip in the industry, providing cheer to employees who continue to upgrade their skills,” said Nishith Upadhyaya, SHRM India Head – Advisory and Knowledge.
With salary costs getting close to 70 per cent of the project costs, thin margins result in more scrutiny of non-billable resources, according to Vinu Nair, Managing Partner, Antal International Network, India.
The overall job market outlook though appears bullish, the analysts said.
“The demand for laterals with 5-12 years of experience is on the rise and the key for people in this experience range would be to remain hands-on. Director-level roles will remain a notch below recent years, mainly because net new projects are lower,” Nair said.
The business potential for Indian IT and ITeS companies is huge, but they need to work consistently on innovation service quality and cost to attract the rest of the world to continue to invest in India for their offshore/non-customer interface job centres in India, suggested GlobalHunt MD Sunil Goel.
TeamLease’s Chakraborty further said low-skilled jobs are not aspirational for any economy or country in the long run. As a region prospers through increase in per capita income, low-level jobs are either taken over by people from lesser prosperous regions or get automated.
This article was published in Business Standard:http://goo.gl/EqonBU
Latest Blogs
The HR Recruitment Process: More Than Just Hiring People
Walk into any organisation, startup or multinational, and ask what keeps the engine running. It won’t just be tech, products, or processes. It’s people. But...
Read MoreHow Staffing Partners Transform Recruitment & Selection Process
The recruitment and selection process in HRM (Human Resource Management) has evolved significantly, and it plays a pivotal role in shaping the future of any...
Read MoreTalent Acquisition vs Recruitment in Workforce Planning
In many boardroom conversations, “talent acquisition” and “recruitment” are used interchangeably, but the reality is, they’re not the same. While both deal with bringing people...
Read MoreEvolution of Human Resource Management in India
The evolution of human resource management in India is a compelling story of how businesses have transformed their approach to people. What started as a...
Read More5 Key Manpower Supply Strategies for Hiring Better Talent
In today’s competitive job market, ensuring a reliable manpower supply is critical for business continuity and growth. Whether managing large-scale operations or expanding your business,...
Read MoreHot jobs for millennials
Research finds that millennials, born between 1981 and 2000, make for top-notch product designers, store promoters, and research specialists.
Most employers are well aware that the problem isn’t so much attracting Millennials as it is keeping them over a long period of time. To that end, the key is to make it a workplace that is fulfilling to the needs of younger employees; those needs include flexibility in terms of work-life balance, learning & development opportunities, and room for rapid growth.
The list also includes hot jobs for millennials, thanks to the advancements in technology. Many of the jobs on the list didn’t exist a few years ago, jobs like digital marketing manager and web production leads.
Here are the Top 10 Jobs to explore in 2016
1. Web Production Lead: annual median salary 7.5L, Growth Outlook – Positive
Why is it in demand? Complete ownership of the task from start (submitting the task in the queue) to end (till it goes live)
2. Simulation Engineers: annual median salary 4.5L, Growth Outlook – 4%
Why is it in demand: fast product development, lower testing needs, which is highly time consuming, Identify high-value features and technology for simulation products
3. Research Specialist: annual median salary 4.25L, Growth Outlook – 16%
Why is it in demand? Potential Testing skills to research on new drugs, devices and biologics. The tremendous increase in medical technology and information, Improved and streamlined the clinical research programs with most research methodologies in order to shorten the development timelines and control the cost for new product development.
4. Product designer: annual median salary 4.0L, Growth Outlook – Positive
Why is it in demand? India has become the hub for design outsourcing and for foreign corporates and MNCs who are seeking help of Indian design companies to execute quality goods, Indian companies are also increasingly designing their own products, hence recruiting more designers in the sample endeavour.
5. Design Engineer (UniGraphics): annual median salary 3.5L, Growth Outlook – Positive
Why is it in demand – Research new Developments and innovations with original, Turn those research ideas into technical plans, Consider cost, effectiveness and safety of new designs.
6. Sales Executive (PUF Panels): annual median salary 3.2L, Growth Outlook – Positive
Why is it in demand? – Create brand awareness in the market through online & offline Marketing tie-up, initiating various offline activities through corporate tie-ups, Selection and forming alliances with new channel partners.
7. Store Promoter – annual median salary 1.5L, Growth Outlook – Positive
Why is it in demand – Conducting lectures, using films, charts, and/or slide shows, Create a positive image and lead consumers about usage of the product, Distribute product samples, brochures, flyers etc. to source new sales opportunities, Collect real-time feedback, Quick Implementation of Actions on feedback to generate sales.
8. Digital marketing Head – annual median salary 30L, Growth Outlook: 70000 Jobs
Why is it in demand – To meet the growing demand amid a sharp increase in the number of people accessing the internet, It is critical for such companies to have the right person to lead the digital marketing team, Companies across sectors are ramping up their digital marketing teams and the job profile is slowly but surely attracting more attention because it’s seen as relatively stable and talent is as yet scarce.
9. Back office – annual median salary 3.0L, Growth Outlook – Positive
Why is it in demand – Handle customer’s call/queries/mails and provide them effective solutions at ground level, support the existing customers in terms of providing the accurate data, guiding them regarding various investment/financial plans.
10. CNC machine engineer – annual median salary 5.15L, Growth Outlook – 17%
Why is it in demand – Engineers can take advantage of the cost savings accrued by using high end machines to turn raw materials into final products with a high level of accuracy and efficiency what most of the other jobs doesn’t suffice the objectives.
The demand for these jobs is gaining enough steam that institutions of higher education are paying attention and developing some course materials.
Latest Blogs
The HR Recruitment Process: More Than Just Hiring People
Walk into any organisation, startup or multinational, and ask what keeps the engine running. It won’t just be tech, products, or processes. It’s people. But...
Read MoreHow Staffing Partners Transform Recruitment & Selection Process
The recruitment and selection process in HRM (Human Resource Management) has evolved significantly, and it plays a pivotal role in shaping the future of any...
Read MoreTalent Acquisition vs Recruitment in Workforce Planning
In many boardroom conversations, “talent acquisition” and “recruitment” are used interchangeably, but the reality is, they’re not the same. While both deal with bringing people...
Read MoreEvolution of Human Resource Management in India
The evolution of human resource management in India is a compelling story of how businesses have transformed their approach to people. What started as a...
Read More5 Key Manpower Supply Strategies for Hiring Better Talent
In today’s competitive job market, ensuring a reliable manpower supply is critical for business continuity and growth. Whether managing large-scale operations or expanding your business,...
Read MoreJobs Jumla: How Technology is Upending Modi’s Monumental Plans to Put India to Work
An article in ‘The Wire’ talks about Automation is deindustrialising India, which is not sufficiently innovative to face up to the threats posed by artificial intelligence, nor equipped to build on its mainstay capabilities in agriculture and other traditional industries; along with inputs from Manish Sabharwal.
Automation is deindustrialising India, which is not sufficiently innovative to face up to the threats posed by artificial intelligence, nor equipped to build on its mainstay capabilities in agriculture and other traditional industries.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi alluded, yet again, to the creation of jobs in his Independence Day speech, an economic priority that he has underscored on almost every occasion, both in speeches and at events over the past two years.
“As the scope of work expands, the possibilities of employment generation also increase… today, we have stressed in that direction,” he claimed, pointing to India’s credentials as the largest manufacturer of vehicles, leading exporter of software and home to the world’s most ambitious public sanitation programme that has purportedly led to the construction of two crore toilets under his regime.
All of this, coupled with investments in new factories that the prime minister seemed to suggest in his speech, has led to employment generation and new job opportunities for India’s 800 million who are under the age of 35.
A granular look at employment trends, however, shows that job creation dropped significantly during Modi’s reign – down from 4.2 lakh incremental jobs created during January-December 2014 to 1.35 lakh in the following year across eight core sectors. Also, a structural shift in India’s labour markets – an increased emphasis on automation across industries and the inability of policy makers in gauging the looming threats posed by mega tech trends – has made an already monumental task of providing jobs to 12 million new market entrants every year over the next two decades, into an exceptionally onerous one for the NDA government.
Disruptive bots
The fact that India lacks the coping mechanisms to deal with large-scale tech disruptions to its labour markets has been put on show by its IT services sector.
The sector has been the solitary engine for job growth in the past two decades – when India was transformed from a largely agrarian nation to a services-driven economy, bypassing the traditional manufacturing-led industrial expansion that could absorb millions of new graduates into the workforce.
However, as machines and robots now undertake the simple, manual tasks that lakhs of engineering graduates traditionally performed, India’s outsourcing job boom has come under threat. Faced with a scenario of rapidly shrinking employment opportunities in the IT sector, it is for the first time since 2009 that campus recruitment for engineering graduates is expected to decline – according to the IT industry body NASSCOM, which predicted a 20% drop in its most recent outlook.
India’s IT companies hire around 2-2.5 lakh of the roughly 14-15 lakh engineering graduates every year. But, as delivery functions are getting automated, a minimum of 10% of the incremental jobs will “disappear”, Mohandas Pai, the former CFO and HR head at Infosys, recently told PTI.
A US-based research firm, HfS Research, has calculated the damage at 6.4 lakh “low-skilled” IT jobs over the next 5 years.
“We’ve deployed an element of automation across all our new projects in the last one year,” said L Ravichandran, the president and chief operating officer of Tech Mahindra, India’s 5th largest IT company that launched its robotics automation and artificial intelligence (AI) framework, AQT, last year. “Not only have we been able to see improved process efficiencies, but also reduce manual errors. [It] saves delivery time, while skilling our hires to do more value tasks”.
Such benefits have, however, come as a direct cost to job creation, a fact that has openly been acknowledged by India’s tech giants. Tech Mahindra, in fact, has an index that tracks the decrease in manpower needed per project, while Wipro, in an analyst conference call last year, is openly known to have admitted to the fact that automation, through its AI platform Holmes, could reduce its staff count by at least a third.
TCS and Infosys, the other IT bellwethers, who also use their own AI platforms – Ignio and Mana – are rapidly adapting to the new environment to make their companies more productive and increase their revenue per employee.
The effects of this are increasingly becoming more noticeable than ever. India’s top five IT vendors, including Cognizant, reported a 24% year-on-year decline in hiring, as per a recent analysis by Centrum Broking.
There is also a question mark over whether India’s economy has the replacement capacity to take up this pool, barring, as Pai quipped, a driving job with taxi aggregators such as Ola and Uber which have seen a migration of software engineers to them in the recent times.
“There are other areas of absorption in the economy, but it is true that the employment elasticity of growth in IT companies has definitely come down,” said Manish Sabharwal, Chairman and Co-Founder of TeamLease Services, a leading staffing company. “IT companies can clock higher growth numbers with far fewer numbers of people today”.
Man vs machine
This is a great cause of worry for the government. Even more so given that across India’s manufacturing spectrum as well – which is a new thrust area for the Modi government with initiatives like ‘Make in India’ designed specifically to give the sector a fillip – the jobs pledge is sounding increasingly like a day-time reverie.
A trip to Ludhiana’s famed knitwear and textiles cluster points to the anxieties that economists have expressed about modern machinery replacing human toil. At Jyoti Textile Mills – a lungi manufacturing unit with 60 whirring shuttle looms – four new upgraded machines will replace the job of 12 looms and improve production by three times in the coming years.
“Erratic labour conditions and changing trends, which demand a better finish is forcing us to automate,” said Kshitij Ghai, the proprietor of this small scale enterprise.
These ground realities are borne out by wider studies like the one jointly conducted by industry body Texprocil and Ernst & Young, which suggests that even as the market size of textiles grows by 40% to $142 billion in the next five years, industrial automation is likely to hit job creation significantly. The new textiles policy targets one crore new jobs, but the study estimates that realistically, only 29 lakh jobs are likely to be created in the next five years.
Questions are also being raised about how significantly the ‘Make in India’ bogie will contribute to the targeted job growth, which is one of its key stated goals.
While foreign direct investment in India surged to $62 billion between October 2014 and May 2016, a chunk of it has gone to the services sector and what has come into manufacturing under ‘Make in India’ is unlikely to spur job figures, reckon experts.
Reports show how robots have gradually begun taking over functions across an array of automobile plants that are owned by global players such as Volkswagen, Ford and Hyundai in India. There is no reason to believe that the new FDI money that comes in is any less likely to sacrifice the cost and product efficiencies of industrial automation – a global trend – for the altruistic purpose of mass job creation.
Global practices of greenfield investors, in fact, don’t do much to instil confidence on this front. The Taiwanese contract electronics manufacturer, Foxconn, which has signed a pact to invest $5 billion over five years in a semi-conductor facility in Maharashtra – which is amongst the largest single FDI flow into the country – has said that it expects to generate employment for about 50,000 people in the country. But across its other global factories, the Apple and Samsung supplier has replaced 60,000 factory workers with robots in May of this year. It remains to be seen whether things will pan out as planned for Foxconn’s hiring plans back home, particularly given how little has changed in terms of labour reform and the other byzantine regulations that guide large scale industries.
An existential crisis
Modi inherited from the previous government a sorry legacy of what has come to be known as a decade of “jobless growth”. But clearly, as the last two years have shown, his problems have only been compounded by these new existential threats that weren’t entirely unforeseen, but are being rather hugely underestimated as unrealistic job promises are being doled out.
The government is now faced with a double whammy of a demand destruction in the developed West (which has affected job creating export sectors) met with the rise of machines that is causing a labour market destruction across the economy. It is prematurely deindustrialising a country that is neither sufficiently innovative to face up to the threats posed by artificial intelligence, nor equipped with the strength and willingness to build on its mainstay capabilities in agriculture and other traditional industries.
This has great social and political implications, as Aseem Shrivastava, a Delhi-based economist explains in the Economic & Political Weekly, “the drying up of jobs in the mainstream corporate-led economy means there is suddenly far greater demand for government positions and for caste-based reservations for such jobs.”
It also puts into question the very premise of the argument posited by successive liberal governments and policymakers that, with development, millions of Indians will migrate from occupations such as agriculture to more “productive” and “lucrative” ones in the industrial and services sector.
“This promise is far from being met. However, it exists as a real fantasy in the minds of millions of young Indians… The flood tide of support from urban and urbanising youth, which was crucial in bringing Narendra Modi and the [BJP] to office, is more than likely to turn against him in 2019, unless he achieves the impossible and in fact delivers the promised jobs,” warns Shrivastava. “The data is not on his side.”
This article was published in The Wire
Latest Blogs
The HR Recruitment Process: More Than Just Hiring People
Walk into any organisation, startup or multinational, and ask what keeps the engine running. It won’t just be tech, products, or processes. It’s people. But...
Read MoreHow Staffing Partners Transform Recruitment & Selection Process
The recruitment and selection process in HRM (Human Resource Management) has evolved significantly, and it plays a pivotal role in shaping the future of any...
Read MoreTalent Acquisition vs Recruitment in Workforce Planning
In many boardroom conversations, “talent acquisition” and “recruitment” are used interchangeably, but the reality is, they’re not the same. While both deal with bringing people...
Read MoreEvolution of Human Resource Management in India
The evolution of human resource management in India is a compelling story of how businesses have transformed their approach to people. What started as a...
Read More5 Key Manpower Supply Strategies for Hiring Better Talent
In today’s competitive job market, ensuring a reliable manpower supply is critical for business continuity and growth. Whether managing large-scale operations or expanding your business,...
Read More